I agree with most of the opinions shared here. Reviews can be useful, but they should never be the deciding factor. Unfortunately, many review sites contain sponsored or incentivized reviews, so it's difficult to know which ones reflect real customer experiences.
The simplest approach is to buy a hosting plan for one month. During that time, open a few support tickets with different types of questions, monitor uptime and performance, and evaluate how the provider handles real-world situations. After that, decide whether they're worth your long-term business.
If I were evaluating a hosting company today, one of the first things I'd look for is a public status/health check page. A provider that is confident in its infrastructure is usually transparent about outages, maintenance, and historical uptime. Companies that openly publish their operational status tend to inspire much more confidence than those that rely only on marketing claims and review scores.