Given the nature of a public forum, a lot of users gather whether they have an interest in offer/request from an initial post. If their personal conclusion tells them a certain business practice does not sound good to them, or sounds suspicious, they won't even bother following up on it.
Based on the lack of information you provided in the first post, I thought exactly the same as x9master, thus raised points by that member were on the spot right. I didn't say you didn't answer the questions, but you did think it was criticism.
Best,